Our Favorite Things To Do
Recreation
Camp Hero
Our engagement spot and the inspiration for Hawkins Lab in Stranger Things. Atlantic bluffs meet WWII towers and wild time travel conspiracy theories.
Montauk Downs
Top 100 public golf course with ocean views in the US. Jordan hasn't been finding much joy here lately but maybe you'll have better luck.
Lighthouse
Commissioned by George Washington in 1792. Fourth-oldest active lighthouse in America and still guides ships 19 miles out to sea.
Ditch Plains
Montauk's most consistent surf break and world famous surfing spot. Great waves whether you're catching them or watching from the sand.
Puff & Putt
Nestled in on Fort Pond's waterfront, Puff 'n' Putt offers an 18-hole pirate-themed mini golf course perfect for some friendly competition.
Hike to Warhol Preserve
Take a scenic hike along the bluffs to catch glimpses of the legendary Eothen estate, where Warhol entertained an extraordinary roster of guests. Make sure to check for ticks!
Food
Amber Waves
Non-profit farm, market, and café in Amagansett with over 350 varieties of vegetables, herbs, and flowers. You’ll never want to shop at a regular grocery store again.
Finis
We love this shop in Amagansett – their white pizza and classic tomato slice are our faves. Thin, crispy New York-style pies that won’t leave you in a food coma. Somewhere between an 8.3 – 10 out of 10 on the local scale.
Tony’s Meat Market
High quality sandwiches. Jordan says, “try the homemade roast beef with provolone or go for a chicken cutlet with mozzarella”. Seriously, a good deli for a sandwich.
Joni’s
Our go-to spot – Colleen loves the Acai bowl and Jordan never misses his SMOKIN Jack! turkey wrap (hold the mayo).
The Dock
Waterfront seafood with fresh-off-the-boat catches in Montauk Harbor. Our go-to spot. Jordan gets the mahi mahi bites and catch of the day and Colleen dogs down on jalapeño poppers and a salad.
Mostrador
Oceanfront counter service at Marram Hotel steps from the Atlantic. Great views and a good spot to hang and be healthy.